Sold
Sold
$388,000
6431 Highway 51
Burlington Flats , New York

Listing Agent

Jessica Mileto Lead Listing Agent

Listing Description

Sold 6/15/26

Client Testimonial: “Moving from NYC to Upstate? You need Jessica. Buying a home can feel overwhelming, and having someone savvy, responsive, and unflappable makes all the difference. Jessica knows the region inside and out, and her network of local pros helps smooth out every bump in the road. If you’re dreaming of an Upstate life, she’s the one who can make it real. Truly — call her.” -Ian

Experience the quintessential Upstate New York lifestyle on this picturesque 15-acre farmstead, complete with affordable taxes and timeless charm. Anchored by a beautifully preserved Circa 1860 Greek Revival home, this 4–5 bedroom, 3-bath residence seamlessly blends historic character with modern comfort. Wide-plank wood floors, a spacious hickory kitchen with cooking island, gas fireplace, and inviting gathering spaces make this home ideal for both everyday living and effortless entertaining. Comfortable and cozy spaces flow seamlessly adorning the tranquil backyard sanctuary, while offering the convenience of a first-floor bedroom, bath, and laundry, along with formal dining, living, and office spaces providing flexibility for work, hosting, or relaxation. Upstairs, you’ll find two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and a private wing complete with generous sleeping quarters and bath—perfect for guests or multigenerational living. A classic two-story Dutch barn and additional shed offer abundant storage, workshop potential, or space for your hobby farm vision. The acreage has recently welcomed cows, horses, and a variety of barnyard companions, making this property ideal for agricultural or recreational pursuits. Bordering along a stream, with sweeping views, and serene natural surroundings all adding to the property’s undeniable appeal, just 20 minutes from Cooperstown. Once operated as a B&B, this easily accessible country retreat invites endless possibilities. Schedule your visit today to experience this exceptional home with several recent improvements! The farm equipment, contents of barn, shed and some antique furnishings will be available.

Exclusively Listed by Katherine Fistrowitz of CARE Brokerage.

Buyer Representation: Jessica Mileto, KWUNYP

MLS Listing

Property Details

Price $388,000
Address 6431 Highway 51
City Burlington Flats
State New York
Zip Code 13315
County Otsego
MLS R1651598
Year Built 1867
Floors 2
Square Feet 2350
Acres 15
Bedrooms 4
Bathrooms 3

Map

Sold
$388,000
6431 Highway 51
Burlington Flats, New York
Bed4 Bath3 Sqft2350 sqft

Listing Agent

Jessica Mileto Lead Listing Agent